History Courses For Dr. Christopher C. Lovett
Introduction Age of Empire Age of Total War Baseball Bibliographies Cloak & Dagger Gulf Wars Harry & Ike Holocaust KSCHE Middle East Modern Civ Soviet Union Terrorism Online Vietnam World Since 1945 World War I World War II WWII Roundtable

Updated as of 2 October 05

Today in History:

On October 2, 1780, Major John Andrι, a British spy associated with Benedict Arnold, was executed on this day in history. 

Quote of the Day:

"In my view we are much worse off now than when we went into Iraq. This is not a partisan position. I voted for these guys."

A senior figure at a military-sponsored think tank as told to James Fallows in "Bush's Lost Year" in The Atlantic Monthly (Oct. 2004)

Was the 2004 Election Stolen?

Take the Ann Coulter Quiz

Where are you politically? Take the Neocon Quiz and find out.

"History is Far too Important to be left to History Professors"

Teaching isn't such a novel idea

Announcements

Age of Despotism

Age of Total War

Current  History

Dictators and Dems

DDE in War & Peace

Splendid Little Wars

Terrorism Online

World War II Online

Bibliography: History of Disease

Bioterrorism

Contemporary Terrorist Organizations

How to Write an Essay

Map of Islamic Terrorist Cells in the U.S.A.

PowerPoint Notes

Reaction Papers

TASK Information Updates

Terrorism Cybrary

Terrorism Filmography

Terrorism Glossary

new.gif (2881 bytes)Yahoo! Groups TASK Teachers

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Denying The Obvious: The Holocaust and Modern Memory

Holocaust

Fall 2008

Some Thoughts

•      Holocaust Denial is a major component of the racist and extreme right.

•      Both in the United States and in Europe.

•      The extreme right, i.e, David Duke and Willis Carto, have published some of the worst examples.

•      The deny the Anne Frank’s Diary, the gas chambers at Auschwitz, and the actual number of victims.

•      Sometimes, defenders of the First Amendment, for example Noam Chomsky, has defended some of the most egregious figures in the denial movement.

Questioning World War I

•       Americans led the war in questioning the origins of World War I.

•       Sidney B. Fay lead the way.

•       Followed by Harry Elmer Barnes, who wrote The Genesis of the World War.

•       He became the dean of Holocaust deniers.

•       Charles Beard, a leading American historian followed with questioning FDR’s motives in 1941.

Even Henry Ford Played a Part

•       Henry Ford in his Dearborn Independent published the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

•       Which is still in publication, even when we know that they are a fraud.

•       After World War II, John T. Flynn published The Roossevelt Myth.

•       Flynn argued that the only victor in World War II was Stalin.

The Rise of the Relativists

•       Some pointed to the transfer of Germans from the lost territories.

•       Joe McCarthy defended the murderers of Malmedy and put the U.S. Army on trial after World War II.

•       Many of the articles in the IHR defend Germany and the Nazis.

•       The Liberty Lobby is dedicated to just that effort.

The First Attempts to Deny the Holocaust

•      The first attempt came in France with Maurice Bardeche.

•      Bardeche was a fascist and a collaborator during the war.

•      In 1947, he wrote Letter to Francois Mauriac, in which he defended collaboration with the Nazis during the war.

•      In a subsequent book, Nuremberg or the Promised Land, he claimed that the evidence at the IWCT was doctored.

•      He argued that the Germans did not commit atrocities during the war.

•      The real culprit were the Jews.

•      He was a committed fascist all of his life.

The Tale of Paul Rassinier

•       He was a former Communist.

•       He spent time in Buchenwald and Dora.

•       He then wrote Crossing the Line.

•       In this book he claimed that the German crimes during the Holocaust were exaggerated.

•       For the next two decades he  wrote a number of books that were filled with lies and distortions.

•       In 1977, he wrote a single volume entitled Debunking the Genocide Myth. 

The Consequence of the European Deniers

•      The early deniers went after the numbers of victims.

•      Combined with the American revisionists, they set the ground work for problems we currently face today.

The Early Years in Cold War America

•      The Cold War help foster a growth of denial.

•      Often anti-Semitism was a major factor.

•      Many of the early American deniers were influenced by Paul Rassinier.

•      Those deniers thought the markets were controlled by International Zionism.

•      One early denier, W. D. Herrstrom, in Bible News Flashes (1952) argued that the “victims” of the alleged Holocaust were not victims at all, but illegal aliens in the U.S.

Denial and American Fascism

•       The most famous American Nazi, George Lincoln Rockwell, called the Holocaust “a monstrous and profitable fraud.”

•       Harry Elmer Barnes gave the movement legitimacy.

•       After World War II, he claimed that Hitler’s aims were legitimate.

•       In 1952, he claimed that FDR’s policies were the “greatest crime in human history.

Barnes Helps Other Deniers

•       Barnes helped David Leslie Hoggan publish his book, The Forced War.

•       Hoggan argued that Hitler was forced into the conflict.

•       Barnes then in the American Mercury attacked the Holocaust in “The Zionist Fraud.”

•       He saw the Einsatzgruppen as soldiers fighting the Reds in Russia.

•       He always attacked his critics with venom, often in anti-Semitic tones.

General Trends

•      Fringe academics were attracted to denying the Holocaust.

•      Austin J. App was one such character.

•      He never had the academic record of Barnes.

•      He considered the Holocaust a hoax.

•      He felt that the Holocaust was an unjustified moral burden on Germany.

•      His field was English literature.

•      He claimed that Henry Morganthau hoodwinked FDR.

•      He denied Hitler’s evil intent, since Hitler was a man of art, not of war.

•      Furthermore, the Allies started the war.

Austin P. Apps Later Career

•       In 1945, he claimed that the Germans did not commit any atrocities during the war.

•       In 1946, he challenged the numbers of victims.

•       The Holocaust in his mind was the work of “Talmudists and Bolsheviks.”

•       He continued this charge in 1973 with the publication of his book The Six Million Swindle.

App’s Denial of Jewish Victims

•      He argued that immigration not annihilation was the goal of the Reich.

•      Gas was not used a Auschwitz.

•      The alleged victims were living in the Soviet Union.

•      The Holocaust is perpetuated by the Jewish controlled media.

•      The Jews who actually died were enemies of the Reich.

•      He became a pillar of anti-Semitic and Holocaust denial in the U.S. and Europe.

General Trends of Holocaust Denial

•       Starting in the 1960s and 1970s Fascism was on the upsurge.

•       In 1977, the National Front in the UK polled 250,000 votes.

•       The National Front embraced racism, ethnocentrism, and nationalism.

•       The only way for fascism to grow was to deny the Holocaust.

The Growth in the U.S.

•      Deniers found support in the person of Willis Carto.

•      Who gained control of the Liberty Lobby.

•      Who in turn owned Noontide Press.

•      Which published The Myth of the Six Million.

•      Who started the Institute for Historical Review.

•      The long term objective of Carto was to make political fascism possible.

•      Later on, Carto would attempt to wreck the IHR.

•      The funding came from the heirs of Thomas Edison.

The Coming of Arthur Butz: The Poster Scholar for the Neo-Nazis and Klan

•       He was a tenured faculty member at Northwestern since 1974.

•       There he wrote The Hoax of the Twentieth Century.

•       Since he talk at Northwestern, he gave denial respectability.

•       Unlike other deniers, he never claimed that Jews were not a threat.

•       He tried to present the image that he was a legitimate scholar and critical of anti-Semitism

Butz in the 1980s

•      By 1985, he was giving presentations for Louis Farakhan.

•      He utilized conspiracy arguments blended with traditional anti-Semitism that supported his twisted logic.

•      He claimed the the government has been forging documents about the Holocaust.

•      His main venue was the Institute for Historical Review.

Why Traditional Scholars Have Not Accept the Denier Position?

•      Butz argued that traditional scholars were frightened to tell the truth.

•      As a consequence, non-historians have picked up the argument by default.

•      Butz did have to admit that most deniers were anti-Semitic.

•      Still, since the “normal” channels of scholarship were closed to them, they had to go to the IHR.

Keys to Butz

•       The Holocaust is perpetuated by “forged” documents.

•       The confessions of German war criminals were coerced.

•       Consequently, the media has contributed to what he called “the Holocaust legend.”

•       Most survivors were lying about what had happened so long ago.

The Case of Ernst Zundel

•       He was a German citizen living in Canada under immigrant status.

•       In 1984 he was arrested for instigating racial and social intolerance.

•       He wrote anti-Semitic tracts – The West, War, and Islam and We Love You Adolf Hitler.

•       In 1985, he was found guilty and won on appeal.

•       In the second trial, David Irving and Fred Leuchter came to his defense.  

The Leuchter Report

•      Upon the urgings of other deniers, he went to Auschwitz/Birkenau and Majdanek in Poland.

•      He brought with him a draftsman, filmmaker, and interpreter.

•      He gathered, or he claimed, “forensic samples” at the site.

•      He then had the results published in what deniers called the Leuchter Report.

•      Irving, Zundel, and others published it.

•      Leuchter denied that the sites were gas chambers.

•      A Canadian court attacked the authenticity of the report as well as the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.

What Is The Objective of the Deniers?

You Can Read More About It