Problems for the Democracies and the Rise of Japan

Age of Total War

Fall 2003

The General World Situation

•       The Depression exacerbated the tensions in Europe and Asia.

•       Britain was contending not only with the Depression.

•       But also the India issue.

•       The dictatorship of Primo de Rivera came to an end.

•       Japan found the Kwantung Army was out of control.

•       While Herbert Hoover decided to suspend debt repayment.

Situation in 1931

•       Austria began in a very unfavorable situation.

•       Most profitable portions of the state were taken from her.

•       Leaving only a rump after 1919.

•       Austria was only kept afloat by foreign loans throughout the 1920s.

•       The situation became worse when the World Court denied the plan for union with Germany.

The Political Situation

•       Austria was divided between Social Democrats.

•       Whose strength was in Vienna.

•       And Christian Socialists…more conservative.

•       Strength was in the rural regions.

•       Ignatius Seipel, a Catholic Priest, was Chancellor from 1922-24 and 1926-29.

The Government of Austria

•       The Seipel government was authoritarian.

•       Was more so under Seipel’s disciple, Engelbert Dollfuss.

•       Better known as Millimetternich because of his height.

•       Dollfuss took over when the Depression was destroying the last vestiges of old Austria.

•       Pitting the parties against each other.

Political Problems in Austria

•      The Communists were gaining control over the leftwing of the Social Democrats.

•      The Nationalists were falling under the sway of the National Socialists.

•      The National Socialists (NSDAP) took orders from Berlin…who advocated union with the Reich.

•      Who supported Dollfuss?

Dollfuss Found Support From the Heimwehr

•       Dollfuss could turn to Prince Starhemberg…from an old Austrian family.

•       He created the Heimwehr.

•       Which was the “Home Guard.”

•       Who received arms from Italy, via Mussolini.

•       Who did not want Austria merged with Germany.

•       But the greater danger came from the extreme left.

The Heimwehr

•       Throughout 1933 the Heimwehr grew.

•       Had enough arms to filed an army of 500,000 men.

•       With tanks and howitzers to sustain combat for a considerable time.

•       Dollfuss then decided to dissolve the Parliament.

•       But that was enough for Dollfuss. 

Moving Against the Left

•       Starting in 1934 Dollfuss moved against the left.

•       Rounding up leftist leaders.

•       Occupying  union halls.

•       Fighting started in rural towns.

•       Then soon spread to the working class districts of Vienna.

•       Fighting started on Feb. 12, 1934, at the Karl Marx Hof.

After Crushing the Socialists

•       Parliament met once more.

•       Dollfuss and his Vice Chancellor, Maj. Emil Fey, then ruled as dictators.

•       Dollfuss established a cooperative constitution.

•       The NSDAP was plotting too.

•       And in July 25, 1934, the Nazis tried a putsch.

•       And Dollfuss was killed and so was Frey.

Mussolini Moves

•       Mussolini moved four divisions to the Brenner Pass.

•       The Duce declares that he would support the independence of Austria.

•       Hitler claimed that he was not involve.

•       Disavowed any responsibility.

•       The new chancellor, Kurt von Schuschnigg took over and continued Dollfuss’s policies.

•       But Hitler still plotted.

General Trends

•       The trend was toward dictatorship in the region.

•       Democracy never took root even after the collapse of Bela Kun in Hungary.

•       When the Communists were suppressed, Admiral Horthy, the liberator of Budapest, became Regent.

•       Waiting for the return of the Habsburg.

•       The reactionaries ruled from 1921-31 under Count Bethlen.

The Depression and Hungary

•       Count Bethlen supported the Magyar nobility restore their feudal rights.

•       Restricting the suffrage.

•       Opposing agrarian reform.

•       Finally the Depression brought him down.

•       To be replaced by Julius Gombos, who tightened the authoritarian regime further.

•       And turned Hungary into a client of Hitler and the Nazis.

The Situation in Yugoslavia

•       In Yugoslavia the situation was exasperated between Croats and Serbs.

•       Catholic and Orthodox.

•       In 1929, King Alexander established a dictatorship.

•       And remained linked to France, until he was assassinated in 1934.

•       His successor, Peter II flirted with both Mussolini and Hitler until 1941.

The Situation in Rumania

•       Rumania gave the appearance of having a parliamentary government.

•       Which worked under the Peasant Party and Liberals.

•       In 1930, King Carol had to renounce the throne because of his liaison with a “reputation.”

•       Anti-Semitism grew.

•       So did the Iron Guard.

•       By 1938, a royal dictatorship was in place.

Bulgaria and King Boris III

•       Political assassinations limited democratic development.

•       The Communist Party was very active and bombed the Cathedral in Sofia in 1925.

•       But contributed to the rise of Bulgarian fascist fighting groups.

•       Rightists attempted to take control in 1934 and 1935.

•       Forcing Boris III to establish a dictatorship in 1936. 

The New Chancellor

•       Hitler had to be careful.

•       Since Hindenburg did not trust him.

•       Elections were scheduled for March 1933.

•       The new minister of interior for Prussia, Goering, used the police, augmented by the SA/SS to disrupt Nazi opponents.

•       Few dared to make speeches opposed to the Nazis.

•       Those that did, did so at there own peril.

When Terror Was Not Enough

•       Intimidation was not enough.

•       Something else was needed to frighten the Parties to give Hitler additional powers.

•       Something he could pin on the “Bolsheviks.”

•       The result was the Reichstag Fire of February 27, 1933.

•       The Nazis blamed Marinus van der Lubbe.

•       But in 1942, Goering boasted that he did it.

Hindenburg Gives Hitler Additional Powers

•       Presidential Decree “for the protection of the people and the state.”

•       Signed by Hindenburg on Feb. 28, 1933.

•       Suspended civil and individual rights.

•       Communists, Socialists, and other enemies were arrested.

•       Even despite those measures, 56% of the electorate still opposed Hitler and the NSDAP. 

Destroying the Opposition

•       Using the decree of Feb. 28th.

•       Hitler had all opponents arrested.

•       Political parties were busted.

•       On March 23, the Reichstag passed the “Enabling Act.”

•       Or the Law for Relieving the Distress of the People and the Reich.”

•       Only the Socialists voted against it…the Center supported it.

•       It passed 441 to 84.

In Full Control

•       The first result was Gleichschaltung or Coordination.

•       First step was the abolition of all the German states.

•       All sovereign power was given to the Reich government.

•       All political parties were outlawed except for the NSDAP on July 14, 1933.

•       Trade unions were dissolved and place under the Reich’s Labor Front under Robert Ley.

•       Under the “Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service” Non-Aryans were driven from the civil service.

•       Hitler reached a Concordat with the Vatican and at the same time broke it.

•       Pope Pius XI responded by the encyclical “Burning Sorrow.”

•       Protestants and Newspapers also fell under control too.

The Subordination of the Army and Party

•       Hindenburg was dying and Hitler sought the support of the Generals.

•       What cold either side give each other?

•       What did each side want?

•       The army want the power of the SA broken.

•       Rohm saw the SA as a way to replace the Army.

•       Discussions took place on the

The Night of the Long Knives

•       On June 21, 1934, Hindenburg was in declining health.

•       Bloomberg told Hitler that if he could not control the SA, than the Army would.

•       Himmler and Heydrich then spread rumors that the SA was planning violence.

•       Secretly the Army provided support for the SS to destroy the SA.

•       This happened on the night of June 30, 1934.

The Victims

•       Kurt von Schleicher and his wife.

•       Gustav von Kahr.

•       Ernst Rohm and most of his associates.

•       But still this was not enough.

•       The old guard in the Army had to be silenced too.

Destroying the Independence of the Army

•       After the destruction of the SA the Army now swore loyalty to Hitler’s persons.

•       The German generals were suffering delusions if they thought they could control Hitler.

•       After 1936, the officer corps was too infiltrated by Nazi influences.

•       Then in 1938, Hitler weakened the Army further b the scandals of Gen. Von Fritsch and Von Bloomberg.

It Rains In Spain Rarely on the Plain

•       There were serious problems in Spain.

•       Dating back to the Spanish defeat in the war with the USA.

•       During World War I, Spain was neutral.

•       But there were internal forces weakening Spain.

•       There were internal governmental issues that divided the nation.

•       Then their were colonial problems with the Riff.

Disaster with the Riff

•       The Riff crisis weakened the public’s faith in the monarchy.

•       King Alfonso XIII was involved in the planning of the Battle of Anual in 1921.

•       The battle itself contributed to the deaths of 10,000 Spaniards.

•       If that was bad enough.

•       Another 15,000 were taken prisoner.

•       To save the regime, Alfonso came up with a plot.

•       To have Capt. Gen. Don Miguel Primo de Rivera to take over the government.

Taking Over for Alfonso

•       Primo de Rivera took over in Sept. 1923.

•       His new regime was very similar to the what Mussolini did.

•       Both Alfonso and de Rivera developed cordial relations with Mussolini.

•       Oppositional parties were banned.

•       Universities and newspapers were tightly controlled.

Trying to Make the State Effective

•      Showed a new vigor to make the state functional.

•      Modernized the transportation net.

•      Working with the French, the Riff War was settled in 1926.

•      But there were obvious problems.

•      Primo de Rivera never appealed to the young or the intelligentsia.

•      Traditional conservatives of the fascist bent shied away from Primo de Rivera.

•      Even the Army had its doubts about de Rivera.

The Depression

•      Primo de Rivera resigned in Jan. 1930.

•      The following year, Alfonso XIII went into exile.

•      On April 13, 1931, the Republic was proclaimed.

•      The new Constitution of Dec. 1931 declared that Spain was a Worker’s Republic.

•      Legislative power was placed in the hands of a single legislative chamber known as the Cortes.

The Spanish Republic

•       The ministry was responsible to the Cortes.

•       The newly elected President was Alcala Zamora.

•       The Prime Minster was Manuel Azana.

•       The new government went after the old order.

•       In order to destroy them.

•       At a terrible price.

Targets of the New State

•       The Church.

•       The Plutocracy.

•       The Army.

•       The Jesuit order was expelled.

•       Church schools were closed.

•       State schools were introduced.

•       Large estates were confiscated.

•       RR and Bank of Spain was nationalized.

•       Social Security and the eight-hour day was introduced.

•       The officer corps was cut in half.

Impact on Remaking Spain

•       Peasant rioting.

•       Military plots.

•       Anarchist outrages.

•       Monarchist agitation.

•       Separatist movements.

•       Labor strikes.

•       The birth of the Falange.

•       And a revolt in Asturias.

Formation of the Popular Front

•       In the elections of 1933, the Left suffered a setback.

•       At the start of 1936, moderate Republicans joined with Socialists, Communists, Anarcho-Syndicalists to form a Popular Front government.

•       Like in France.

•       Azana continued the leftward push.

•       The Right claimed that the Government was a tool of Moscow.

The Falange Conducts Terrorism

•      Soon the Falange conducted as series of terrorist acts.

•      Which quickly led to reprisals.

•      A Republican Guard’s officer was assassinated on July 12, 1936.

•      Followed by the murder of Primo de Rivera’s finance minister, Calvo Sotelo.

The Start of the Revolt

•       On July 18, 1936, Gen. Francisco Franco flew from the Canary Islands to Spanish Morocco.

•       This was the start of the revolt.

•       Ten days later, July 28, 1936, the first troops from Morocco arrived in the mainland.

•       The Civil War was on.

Hitler’s Historical Objectives

•       From his early days he was a Pan-German.

•       Attacked the Versailles Settlement.

•       Argued for a restoration of Germany’s 1914 frontiers.

•       As well as expanded eastward in the search of “living space.”

•       A 20th Century version of “Drang Nach Osten.”

Main Mission for Hitler in 1933

•      Gleichschaltung within Germany and the Party.

•      Rebuilding the military.

•      Preparing Germany for an ambitious foreign policy.

Hitler’s Initial Acts

•       Withdrew from the Geneva Disarmament talks.

•       Left the League.

•       All in 1933.

•       Hitler wanted to test the world’s reaction.

•       Hitler claimed that equality was not enough.

•       Hitler declared that he would be willing to establish bilateral agreements with other states.

Why Bilateral Agreements?

•      Easy to break.

•      First agreement was with Poland in January 1934.

•      This reduced the threat to Germany’s eastern frontier, allowing Hitler security.

•      While he prepared to attack later.

The Austrian Debacle

•       The Austrian Nazi Coup of July 1934 worried Europe.

•       Especially with the murder of Dollfuss.

•       The Germans were deeply involved.

•       This allowed Jean Louis Barthou, the French Foreign Minister, to travel throughout Europe.

•       Where he championed the Barthou Plan.

The Barthou Plan

•       He offered a plan for regional collective security.

•       Including Italy, Russia, and the Eastern European states.

•       In many ways it was an Eastern Locarno.

•       These would be linked by a series of mutual defense treaties.

•       With an effort for the Soviets to play a role.

•       This was a threat to Hitler’s ambitions.

Why Did It Fail?

•       Friction between the Czechs and Poles.

•       The Poles would not work with the Russians.

•       The British who did not want to get involved in Eastern Europe.

•       Then the assassination of the King Alexander of Yugoslavia and Barthou in Marsailles in October 1934.

•       After Barthou’s death, the collective security plans collapsed.

Hitler’s Next Moves

•       On March 8, 1935, Hitler announced that Germany had an air force.

•       Then on March 15, Hitler declared that Germany would no longer adhere to the limitations of 100,000 men.

•       The new Wehrmacht would increase to 500,000 men.

•       Hitler guessed that his actions would confuse his foreign enemies.

•       He was right.

The Creation of the Stresa Front

•       The British, French, and Italians met in Stresa.

•       To discuss the German problem.

•       But what killed it was Britain’s deal with Hitler.

•       The British agreed to the Anglo-German Agreement.

•       Where the British agreed to a German navy 35% the size of the Royal Navy.

•       The Anglo-German Naval Agreement gave legitimacy to Hitler’s declarations.

Internal Political Problems, 1923-31

•       Premier Takahashi resigned in 1922 as a consequence of the Washington Naval Conf.

•       The new Premier was Adm. Kato Tomosaburo.

•       He was a naval officer.

•       Who agreed to withdraw Japanese troops from Siberia.

•       Also reduce Japanese troop strength in China.

•       And cut Japanese military expenditures.

Dying in Office

•      Adm. Kato Tomosaburo died in office in 1923.

•      He was followed by Admiral Yamamoto Gombei, who had the unfortunate fate of serving as PM during the Tokyo Earthquake.

Conspiracy Theories

•       The fires of the Earthquake were believed to be started by Korean nationalists.

•       In alliance with Japanese Communists.

•       Who were determined to set up a “revolutionary government.”

•       Japanese police rounded up communists, anarchists, and other radicals.

•       Then there was an attempt on life of the Crown Prince.

Military Expenditures in the Mid-1920s

•      There was a need to cut government expenditures.

•      This was made possible by modernization of the fighting services.

•      The army was cut by four divisions.

•      Improved training programs.

•      And increased indoctrination within Japanese schools.

The Situation by 1927

•       In 1927, Tanaka, the head of the Seiyukai (one of Japan’s political parties).

•       Which meant the Constitutional Government’s Friends Association.

•       He supported a hard line toward China.

•       He tried to support the banks.

•       As well as the Zaibatsu.

•       Tried to care for the needy.

•       As well as crushing the Left.

Dealing With the Depression

•       The Keneikai (Constitutional Association) took over in 1929.

•       The Premier, Hamaguchi tried to get Japan out of the Depression by a policy of retrenchment.

•       On Nov. 14, 1930, he was shot by a young fanatic.

•       His colleague, Minseito took over and tried to get Japan out of the Depression.

Japanese Foreign Policy in the 1920s

•      The Japanese signed the Treaty of Peking in 1925 with the Soviet Union.

•      Normalizing relations between the two powers.

•      Exchanged of diplomats, Soviets recognized the Treaty of Portsmouth.

•      Japanese could fish in Siberian territorial waters.

•      Japan agreed to withdraw from Northern Sakhalin.

•      But there was always serious mistrust beneath the surface.

•      Both the Soviet Union and Japan had plans for Manchuria.

The Situation in Manchuria

•       Premier Tanaka talked of “Positive Foreign Policy” in Asia.

•       What he meant was China and Manchuria.

•       Tanaka’s bellicose tone sparked anti-Japanese riots in China.

•       Young officers in the Kwantung Army took matters into their own hands and assassinated their client –Chang Tso-lin in 1928.

Japan and China

•       Japan wanted a peaceful and anti-Bolshevik.

•       But a united China under Chiang threatened Japan’s interest.

•       Premier Tanaka attempted to halt Chiang’s march to Peking.

•       But something happened.

•       Chang Tso-lin was assassinated in 1928.

•       But now the Japanese Army became a law onto itself.

•       And was out of control.

The Depression on Japan

•      The world-wide Depression came to Japan in 1927.

•      One bank failure led to an avalanche of a similar failures.

•      Soon small business went under.

•      The Zaibatsu took over more concerns.

•      The collapse was increased with the collapse of the American silk market in 1930.

•      Then a short rice crop in northern Japan caused near starvation.

•      Hamaguchi’s remedy as retrenchment he called “rationalization.”

•      His goal was to reduce imports, boost domestic consumption, and increased exports.

•      He took Japan off the Gold Standard.

Impact of the Depression on Japan

•       Welfare of the State took precedent over the individual.

•       Industrial potential should be coordinated with military growth.

•       The economic crisis raised the level of reaction and ultra-nationalism.

•       Ultra-nationalism took on the form of State Shinto.

•       Which was now anti-west, anti-liberal, anti everything.

The Army and Navy

•       The ultranationalists saw the army as their champion.

•       The ranks were peasants, the junior officers were the middle class.

•       Company commanders understood the pain.

•       How bad was it?

•       Fathers sold their daughters into brothels.

•       The Army reflected the emotions of the countryside.

The Junior Officer Corps

•       Well-educated.

•       They saw themselves as the destiny of Japan.

•       Their answer for Japan’s problems was totalitarianism and strength.

•       Not party politics.

•       The use of indoctrination was a tool that helped them.

•       They saw what bourgeois liberalism had caused.

•       To them…it had to be removed.

Where did their Strength Came from?

•      Strength came from Kita’s Outline for the Reconstruction of Japan.

•      The were also influenced by the London Naval Agreement in 1930.

•      In September 1930, high ranking officers created the Sakurakai or “The Cherry Society.”

•      Which was dedicated to the nation’s esprit de corps.

The Cherry Society

•       The Cherry Blossom was their symbol.

•       Their code – duty to the state.

•       “Death is light as a feather, but duty is weightier than a mountain.”

•       Keep officers joined.

•       The organization took off following the assassination of Hamaguchi.

•       They despised liberalism and democracy.

•       Their answer – a military dictatorship

The Plots of the Cherry Society

•      Planned a coup.

•      Including riots and bombing of party headquarters

•      If necessary assassinations

•      All came to naught.

The Showdown with China

•       The situation in China helped the Anti-democratic forces in Japan.

•       China was vulnerable.

•       Young officers of the Kwantung Army took matters into their hands.

•       On the night of September 18-19, 1931, a section of the RR outside of Mukden.

•       The Japanese occupied Manchuria.

•       China was next.